logo

AGENZIA NAZIONALE DI VALUTAZIONE
DEL SISTEMA UNIVERSITARIO E DELLA RICERCA

Home > Atti e Pubblicazioni > Lavori di ricerca > Valutazione della qualità della ricerca

Valutazione della qualità della ricerca

Studi Generali

  • Ancaiani A., Anfossi A., Barbara A., Benedetto S., Blasi B., Carletti V., Cicero T., Ciolfi A., Costa F., Colizza G., Costantini M., Di Cristina F., Ferrara A., Lacatena R.M., Malgarini M., Mazzotta I., Nappi C.A., Romagnosi S., Sileoni S. (2015), Evaluating scientific research in Italy: The 2004-10 research evaluation exercise, in “Research Evaluation”, 24/3, pp. 242-55.
    https://academic.oup.com/rev/article/24/3/242/2503463
  • Benedetto S., Checchi D., Graziosi A., Malgarini M. (2017), Comments on the correspondence “On tit for tat: Franceschini and Maisano versus ANVUR regarding the Italian research assessment exercise VQR 2011–2014”, J. Informetr., 11 (2017), 783-787, in “Journal of Informetrics”, 11/3, pp. 838-40.
  • Benedetto S., Checchi D., Graziosi A., Malgarini M. (2017), Comments on the paper “Critical remarks on the Italian assessment exercise”, Journal of Informetrics, 11 (2017) and pp. 337–357, in “Journal of Informetrics”, 11/2, pp. 622-24.
  • Benedetto S., Malgarini M., Cicero T., Nappi C. (2017), Reply to the letter on Ancaiani et al. “Evaluating Scientific research in Italy: The 2004-10 research evaluation exercise”, in “Research Evaluation”, 26/4, pp. 358-60.
    https://academic.oup.com/rev/article-abstract/26/4/358/3835591
  • Blasi B., Romagnosi S., Bonaccorsi A. (2017), Universities as celebrities? How the media select information from a large Research Assessment Exercise, in “Science and Public Policy”, 45/4, pp. 1-12.
  • Blasi B., Romagnosi S., Bonaccorsi A. (2017), Playing the ranking game. Media Coverage of the Evaluation of the Quality of Research in Italy, in “Higher Education”, 73, pp. 741-57.
  • Checchi D., Mazzotta I., Momigliano S. (2017), Research assessment in Italy: have the results of universities converged?, STI Conference 2017, Paris.
    https://sti2017.paris/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/uni-checchi-et-al.pdf
  • Benedetto S., Cicero T., Malgarini M. (2016), Determinants of Research quality in Italian Universities: evidence from the 2004-2010 evaluation exercise, in “Research Evaluation”, 25/3, pp. 257-63.
  • Bonaccorsi A., Cicero T. (2015), Distributed or concentrated research excellence? Evidence form a large scale research assessment exercise, in “JASIST”, 67/12, pp. 2976-92.
    https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/abs/10.1002/asi.23539

 

Metodologie di valutazione. Bibliometria e peer review

  • Checchi D., Ciolfi A., DeFraja G., Mazzotta I., Verzillo S (2018), Have you read this? Replacing the British REF peer review evaluation with the Italian VQR bibliometric algorithm: An empirical analysis, in “Nottingham School of Economics”, DP N. 329. (pdf)
  • Traag V., Cicero T., Malgarini M., Sarlo S., Waltman L. (2018), Peer review uncertainty at the institutional level, in 23rd International Conference on Science and Technology indicators, Leiden, pp. 990-98.
    https://openaccess.leidenuniv.nl/bitstream/handle/1887/65241/STI2018_paper_166.pdf?sequence=1
  • Cicero T., Malgarini M. (2017), The effect of research collaboration on citation impact: a dynamic panel data analysis?, STI Conference 2017, Paris.
    https://sti2017.paris/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/is2-cicero-on-collaborations.pdf
  • Alfò M., Benedetto S., Malgarini M., Sarlo S. (2017), On the use of Bibliometric information for assessing articles quality: an analysis based on the third Italian evaluation exercise, STI Conference 2017, Paris.
    https://sti2017.paris/wp-content/uploads/2017/11/rp-m-alfo-et-al.pdf
  • Anfossi A., Ciolfi A., Costa F., Parisi G., Benedetto S. (2016), Large-scale assessment of research outputs through a weighted combination of bibliometric indicators, in “Scientometrics”, 107/2, pp. 671-83.
  • Malgarini M., Nappi C.A., Torrini R. (2015), Article and Journal level metrics in massive research evaluation exercises: the Italian case, in Salah A.A., Tonta Y., Akdag Salah A.A., Sugimoto C., Al U. (eds.), Proceedings of ISSI 2015 Istanbul: 15th International Society of Scientometrics and Informetrics Conference, Bogaziçi University Printhouse, Istanbul.
  • Fantoni S., Ancaiani A. (2014), La Valutazione dei prodotti della ricerca ed il suo impatto sul sistema universitario e degli enti di ricerca: il caso italiano, in “Mèlanges de la casa de Velazquez”, 44, pp. 313-18.
  • Benedetto S., Cicero T., Malgarini M. (2014), Research quality, characteristics of publications and socio-demographic characteristics of Universities and Researchers: evidence from the Italian VQR 2004-2010 Evaluation exercise, in Proceedings of the science and technology indicators conference. Context Counts: Pathways to Master Big and Little Data, Leiden.

 

Altri approfondimenti

  • De Santis Puzzonia M., Beltram F., Cicero T., Malgarini M. (2018), Accounting for co-autorship in research evaluation: the case of experimental physics, in 23rd International Conference on Science and Technology indicators, Leiden, pp. 967-74.
    https://openaccess.leidenuniv.nl/bitstream/handle/1887/65214/STI2018_paper_164.pdf?sequence=1
  • Cicero T., Malgarini M. (2017), The effect of research collaboration on citation impact: a dynamic panel data analysis, STI Conference 2017, Paris.
  • Bonaccorsi A., Cicero T. (2016), Non-deterministic ranking of departments and universities, “Journal of Informetrics”, 10/1, 224-37.
    https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1751157716000031
  • Cicero T, Malgarini M. (2016), Measuring research in Humanities and Social Sciences: information from a new Italian data infrastructure, Conference on Science and Technology Indicators, Valencia.
  • Bonaccorsi A., Cicero T., Ferrara A., Malgarini M. (2015), Journal Ratings as Predictors of Article Quality in Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences, in “F1000Research”, 14
    http://f1000research.com/articles/4-196#article-reports

Allegati